Jus soli and on being an alien (2/2)

In the previous part of this post I wrote about the mistake the lady at the international center of my university made when she wrote in a form, I needed for renewing my driving license, that I am a citizen of Kuwait. She thought that I am a Kuwaiti because I was born in Kuwait.

After September 11, 2001 around 2002 or 2003 there was a new regulation, at that time, that all foreigners should register at the nearest immigration office. It was stated that “aliens” need to visit the immigration office once every year. Fortunately, this regulation didn’t last more than a year because the government found it is not convenient for both the foreigners and the locals. The number of the foreign task force and the number of foreign students in the US is so big they can’t afford to waste time and money with such policy especially that registering at the immigration office needs people to cross cities and waste the whole day and maybe more. I guess this is when they decided to replace this policy with the annual renewing of the driving license which is much easier (read part 1).

The process of registration at the immigration office takes half day at least. Forms to fill up, documents to provide, waiting in one room, then waiting in another room, and of course there is the INTERVIEW. I am not sure what they were thinking when they wanted foreigners to go over this process every year. It was waste of time and money.

During my interview at the immigration office, one of the questions the interviewer asked, while she was staring at my Jordanian passport, was “You were born in Kuwait but you don’t have a Kuwaiti citizenship?” I answered “yes”. But the interviewer already knows the answer this wasn’t a question to know about something, it was a kind of a sarcasm question. She had a mocking smile when she asked me this question. In my opinion, she has all the right to smile and to even laugh it out loud. Yes, I was born in Kuwait and grow up there until I was 15 yet I don’t have a Kuwaiti passport even if I lived there for 10 or 20 more years I don’t have the right to be Kuwaiti. So, yes this American lady had all the right to laugh at us, the Arab.

Kuwait is not the only Arab country that does not grant its citizenship to the new born children. I used to think that all Arab countries are against jus soli1 but a Tunisian friend told me that anyone born in Tunisia by default gets a citizenship. I am not very sure about this though but good for them if they do that.

Jordan is no exception and even jus sanguinis2 is not entirely practiced because as far as I know a Jordanian woman married to a non-Jordanian man can’t pass her nationality to her own children.

For countries that grant nationality on the grounds of jus soli I salute you and I tip my hat to you. You deserve all the respect and gratitude for your wisdom. You know when you grant your nationality to a new baby born he will consider you his home. He will love, respect, and defend you. On the other hand, I wonder how a country that does not consider a person who was born, grow up and lived in her soul to love her when she tells him you can live in my house but you are not my son. Meanwhile, I hope Jordan and Syria don’t go to war against each other otherwise I may end up fighting my Syrian nephews (my sister’s kids) in the name of nationalism.

1 jus soli: a rule that the citizenship of a child is determined by the place of its birth.

2 jus sanguinis: a rule that a child’s citizenship is determined by its parents’ citizenship.


4 thoughts on “Jus soli and on being an alien (2/2)

  1. you’d be happy (or not) to hear that jus soli is not applied in a lot of European countries, and some actually did something that isn’t that stupid they created a modified jus soli (they added a few extra rules to the birth place), I can understand why some countries have these rules and regulations it’s to try and prevent illegal immigration and to make sure that it’s citizens know at least something about the country (language, culture…etc). I have seen many US citizens who couldn’t speak English, they are citizens by default because of their birth place.

    1. melicieuse,
      You are right not all European countries grant citizenship to children born in their countries and I think a modified jus soli might solve some of the problems. Yes, some countries want to preserve their culture, religion, language, etc. But these countries are then exploiting their immigrant workers.
      I find it very hard to digest that when a person, who was born and educated in country x, becomes 18 he needs to leave the country he was born and grow up in because he don’t have a citizenship!
      Those people you mentioned who got US citizens because their parents were in the US when they were born and now they don’t speak English because their parents traveled somewhere else may not speak English but at least they appreciate the US.

      1. i agree with you about the person born in country X and educated there and soaked up the citizeness of that country that they call home but then at 18 they have to make do with something else, somewhere they are alien to that they now must make a home of. I don’t think it’s fair or right, alternatives should be given instead of breaking that bond they have cherished since birth (or since a young age)
        now about the American citizens/non-citizens actually I disagree, a lot I have seen only appreciate the fact that they have a choice of “home” they do not necessarily feel a state of belonging to the US but instead a state of the US belonging to them

  2. I have a debate in 5 hours where i need to defend the applicatin of jus soli in a country. Any other good points you can share with me? Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s